1 review
What's great
It is a room with a low-effort activity to occupy your hands, and that combination is far rarer than it sounds. Nothing in it is designed to interrupt a conversation, so a group can be in there for three hours and the game never once demands attention back. We have had entire evenings where the fishing stopped early and nobody noticed or minded.
What needs improvement
If you actually want a fishing game, this is thin. The catch loop has very little depth and once the catalogue is mostly done there is no real reason to cast beyond habit. A slightly more demanding rare-fish chase would give the people who like goals something to do while everyone else talks.
vs Alternatives
Every other game our group owns is a reason to be together with a task attached. This is the only one where the task is optional, and that makes it the one we open when we just want to hear each other.
